This afternoon I had a long phone call from a Latvian who liked my Blogs. It was good natured and educative. But I had a strange feeling from his words that I am inhabiting a strange parallel world here in Riga that many Latvians do not see. Everyone and everything was to blame except normal Latvians for the crisis. I could easily blame the Latvian language. When you translate Articles, Blogs and comments it is clear that no one here knows how to say anything straightforward. The future is never discussed. We go through every historical twist and turn, every shred of irony and call on every allegory we can think of. Every politician stinks, is to blame for something and is dishonest. Or worse all are secret Skele or Lembergs moles under deep deep cover to re-emerge like butterflies from the chrysalis at some later time. Emerging of course to return the country to darkness. And the EU and IMF are totally to blame for all this. No Latvian ever seems to blame themselves, even those who voted for the most corrupt. The language mix is simply impossible to follow for a foreigner. No wonder the Russian speakers stick to Russian to communicate.
But I wonder if we are not reaching a point where something here has to change. This week the Finance Minister Einars Repse has tried (or has actually succeeded - we have to wait and see) to sack the head of the State Revenue Service, Dzintars Jakans. The man has actually been dragging his feet badly on reform. This could be for many reasons and the conspiracy theorists will find loads, but I suspect that he is another past political appointee who like many in power simply has no clue what to do at all. Reform = cuts, doesn't it? The Peoples Party aided by the Goons and Farmers want to use this sacking as an excuse to bring down the government, but conveniently they say they will wait until after the budget is finished at the end of the year. I don't think they know how stupid and weak that makes them look. They had all day Friday to act if they thought they had a real case, but they showed what cowards they are by doing nothing. I guess that's because they know the only person who can do the real budget work is Repse and they have to wait until he is finished.
The real opposition forces in the form of the Oligarchs have been plotting too and Lembergs, Slessers and Skele (he came back the week before last amid trumpets, dancing girls and ribbons to save us all) have formed a new political Axis. Perhaps in half hearted opposition, former President VVF has also thrown her political hat into the ring and started with education reform. The comments were mixed. Many were saying thank God she is back whilst others were more vitriolic about the "Canadian" noting that she was in charge during the 7 fat years and did nothing. Mind she is not an economist!
So what next. If the coalition is going to fall we could be seeing a major turning point in Latvian politics. The end game might be closer than we think. A left turn to corruption and closer ties with Russia, or a right turn to honest government and a chance of a better future. The choice might just come down to the stubbornness of Repse and the decisions of the President. But it is clear that whoever holds the levers of power as we go into the election next summer will have the scope to bribe and fool the population. The big prize is to steal the EU and IMF money - and there are those who eye this greedily.
Sadly, I suspect that good Latvians will wait much longer before they really fight back. They would much rather sing their way to democracy than be active. But that will not work this time folks. The enemy are Latvians too and understand the weakness of this. Those in the countryside just hope the IMF or EU will come on white horses and save them. The Russian speakers keep their heads down and try to get by or even earn enough to live well. Latvian weakness is their political opportunity. And the forces of evil will rub their hands with glee as Latvia becomes more like a failed African state every day. They know that if good men and women continue to do nothing they will be the eventual winners.
And all the while, Russia waits and watches like a hungry vulture.
Saturday, October 24, 2009
Wednesday, October 14, 2009
Have we turned a corner or is this a false dawn?
The last few weeks have been quite difficult for me. I have been trying hard to find new clients and have only found people who were clearly worse off than me. I have been looking at the evidence of what is happening really hard but it is difficult to call. There is a noticeable increase in traffic on the roads, almost back to old times. People are going about their business and daily lives with apparent normality.
But my instinct is to think that this normality covers a whole multitude of sins. The number of Pardod (for sale) signs continues to rise (although I am pleased that my friend Alexanders who runs Mobius selling expensive British Vertu mobile phones has opened another shop in the old town) but in general there still appear to be more businesses closing than opening. There are almost NO adverts on the trams and buses. The exceptions are the big mobile phone companies who are having their own battle royal for our ears and fine words. The prices in most shops have dropped agin. Some have put up prices but they don't seem to have customers. I cannot ever remember seeing any people in one or two shops - but still they stay there. One or two have grasped the nettle and have reinvented themselves to a new lower price level quite successfully. The pubs are mainly empty except for those used by tourists. One nightclub I heard about had no one at all one day last week. Heating bills will arrive this month and that means a direct export to pay for energy- well if people can pay that is. In opposition, the National Bank Governor says we have turned a corner.
We are at the point where the international community (IMF, EU, Swedish banks etc) is demanding that 500m Lats are cut from the government budget. Now some of this will stay in circulation but there are bound to be more effects and they cannot be positive. Tax rises cannot stimulate anything, even accountancy firms!
So my instinct is that what we see is the tip of the iceberg. The big bad bit is under the surface, and with lots of sharp edges. What is amazing is the stoical way society continues its daily round. I suppose that after occupation by the Nazis and USSR, this is just another bit of stress to be suffered. It is just a shame that this time the punishment is being meted out by Latvians upon themselves.
But my instinct is to think that this normality covers a whole multitude of sins. The number of Pardod (for sale) signs continues to rise (although I am pleased that my friend Alexanders who runs Mobius selling expensive British Vertu mobile phones has opened another shop in the old town) but in general there still appear to be more businesses closing than opening. There are almost NO adverts on the trams and buses. The exceptions are the big mobile phone companies who are having their own battle royal for our ears and fine words. The prices in most shops have dropped agin. Some have put up prices but they don't seem to have customers. I cannot ever remember seeing any people in one or two shops - but still they stay there. One or two have grasped the nettle and have reinvented themselves to a new lower price level quite successfully. The pubs are mainly empty except for those used by tourists. One nightclub I heard about had no one at all one day last week. Heating bills will arrive this month and that means a direct export to pay for energy- well if people can pay that is. In opposition, the National Bank Governor says we have turned a corner.
We are at the point where the international community (IMF, EU, Swedish banks etc) is demanding that 500m Lats are cut from the government budget. Now some of this will stay in circulation but there are bound to be more effects and they cannot be positive. Tax rises cannot stimulate anything, even accountancy firms!
So my instinct is that what we see is the tip of the iceberg. The big bad bit is under the surface, and with lots of sharp edges. What is amazing is the stoical way society continues its daily round. I suppose that after occupation by the Nazis and USSR, this is just another bit of stress to be suffered. It is just a shame that this time the punishment is being meted out by Latvians upon themselves.
Saturday, September 26, 2009
Naked Brits perform at Riga opera!


Nothing seems to deter British stag party tourists to Riga from anti social behavior. On a chilly friday evening at 1900hrs this crowd paraded their bare bodies for all to see on the edge of the opera car park. The new British Embassy Charge d'affaire to Riga Dr Anthony Stokes has clearly got his work cut out. This bunch were lucky not to be spotted by the local police.
Sunday, September 20, 2009
Should the Lat be the world reserve currency!
I watched an excellent BBC programme on the world economy this evening. It featured American Robert Mundell, one of the leading monetary economists in the world. He was highlighting the danger of the world reserve currency being the dollar and advocating change. The fact that the Chinese are currently holding 3 TRILLION US dollars I found to be a pretty persuasive argument. If the USA goes so does China, and probably the rest of us too. That means planting even more potatoes in Mazsalaca.
So the Lat seems to me to be a good alternative. My reasons are as follows:
1. Despite the crisis and Latvia going downhill faster than a 4 man bob, the currency has held its (false) value rather well.
2. It has solid IMF backing.
3. There are more than enough trees in Latvia to make all the paper.
4. Being located in the centre of the known world (the EU), Latvia has super transit links all over the place, including a railway line to China to carry all that 3 Trillion dollars worth of Lats
5. It is already the reserve currency for Sweden.
6. The Lat has pretty colours.
To add to the fun, apparently the Godmanis government and National Bank governor acted unconstitutionally when asking for IMF and EU support by not getting the agreement first of Parliament. So the whole support package and subsequent budgetary change is illegal. Will they go to prison?
So the Lat seems to me to be a good alternative. My reasons are as follows:
1. Despite the crisis and Latvia going downhill faster than a 4 man bob, the currency has held its (false) value rather well.
2. It has solid IMF backing.
3. There are more than enough trees in Latvia to make all the paper.
4. Being located in the centre of the known world (the EU), Latvia has super transit links all over the place, including a railway line to China to carry all that 3 Trillion dollars worth of Lats
5. It is already the reserve currency for Sweden.
6. The Lat has pretty colours.
To add to the fun, apparently the Godmanis government and National Bank governor acted unconstitutionally when asking for IMF and EU support by not getting the agreement first of Parliament. So the whole support package and subsequent budgetary change is illegal. Will they go to prison?
Thursday, September 17, 2009
Latvian railways - a rough diamond in need of care and polishing

The "transit" part of Latvian Railways is one of the real national success stories; helped by Russia admittedly, but business is business! 30% of the business is actually privately owned, taking nothing from the government and makes a profit. This is unlike the franchises in many other European countries. The main markets for Latvia are Russia and Belorussian, but they also bring and take goods to the Asian "Stans" and even to far away China. A common experience in Latvia is seeing and hearing the huge oil trains of 40 or more wagons rumbling and schreeching on lines that look simply far too delicate to hold such a heavy monster. I live about 600m from the railway and at night the whole building shakes as the full trains head for Riga and Ventspils ports.
One of the really clever things though is that all the countries share rolling stock. This means that goods or oil are loaded onto the nearest waggon and moved immediately. This greatly speeds up and increases traffic flow, and of course profitability. It is a clever idea that the EU could perhaps copy.
Lines are being slowly upgraded. Thales is upgrading the signalling from Ventspils to the Russian border and Bombardier are doing the next stage. There is though a lot of EU money unspent that the Ministry sadly has not got its act together to organise contracts. It may be lost.
Sadly, the commuter train story is a bit more bleak than transit. The Latvian railways are badly under resourced and also seriously in need of new lighter and smaller trains. At present the old large trains are still pulling heavy, often empty carriages. The government expects the goods profits to be used to subsidise people. This reduces considerably the scope of the railways overall. For tourists the good news is that travel is free. Well that is not quite true but many journeys are one twentieth the cost of their UK equivalent. The trains are frequent and clean, just a tad short on air conditioning in the summer. But you can certainly "see Latvia by train" although some journeys are a bit too much of a forest view for most. With Hotels as littl as 15Euros a night in places like Liepaja, a Latvian train holiday is great value for money
But one real anomaly is the lack of a train between Tallinn and Riga and then south to Poland. This line needs making soon please.
Monday, September 14, 2009
Another brick in the Latvian crisis wall!
The Latvian Building Materials Traders association is holding the government to account for letting contracts to illegal traders. Vice President Guntis Sokolovskis points out that those traders who avoid taxes and don't pay wages are in a better position to get government contracts because they can offer lower prices for goods and services.
The State is apparently still awarding contracts on the basis of lowest price against the technical specifications. Sokolovskis points out that the disordered government policies threaten the honest traders who are paying both white wages and taxes.
There are many companies in the building trade who are owed large amounts of money or owe money. The usual practice is to close the company and then open another one. This year 587 new building supplies companies have newly registered despite the industry contracting severely.
The Association has 34 dealers and a combined annual turnover of 386million Lats.
The State is apparently still awarding contracts on the basis of lowest price against the technical specifications. Sokolovskis points out that the disordered government policies threaten the honest traders who are paying both white wages and taxes.
There are many companies in the building trade who are owed large amounts of money or owe money. The usual practice is to close the company and then open another one. This year 587 new building supplies companies have newly registered despite the industry contracting severely.
The Association has 34 dealers and a combined annual turnover of 386million Lats.
Thursday, September 10, 2009
Mr Repse - 3 Points of contact?
There were two earthquakes in Latvia this week. The first was 2.7 on the Richter Scale and was only 40Km below the surface. Thankfully no one was hurt. But clearly something is happening deep below Latvia and it raises questions about a larger quake sometime in the future. I hope the emergency services are thinking about this carefully.
Back on the surface, the second earthquake was the publication of the Letter of Intent to the IMF from the Government (and I promise this time no dry humour about the IMF - this is too important for that). This document was signed by the government except for the Tautas Party. The TP clearly have objections about the note but no one I talks to thinks that those objections are for the benefit of Latvia. This was confirmed by the rather damning television telephone poll on the news show Kas Notiek Latvia last night.
But to the document itself. There is a rule in climbing that you keep three point of contact as you move forward. Of course we have all seen free climbers on television doing amazing things and breaking this law. But there are two things to remember when watching this, first they are the absolute best in the world, and second, they usually die early because they fall off. The Latvian government in climbing terms is still a novice and needs to move carefully, especially on a crisis climb like this where the overhangs are large and growing worse as we move upwards. Moving(and changing) everything at once may not be a good plan.
I mention all this because the document raises several thoughts in my mind. Firstly there must be someone clever in the finance ministry who can write good corporate "fiscal speak". There is nothing wrong with this because I wrote the first Membership Action Plan for Estonia to gain NATO membership. But whoever wrote it, the Latvian Government signed it and must take full responsibility for the language and the contents. And inside the note there should be a balance between the fiscal social engineering required by the bureaucrats of the IMF and EU, and the reality of running a living, breathing country of real people. This takes compromise, intelligence and strong leadership.
What is worrying is that as far as climbing out of this crisis, the two "legs" of strengthening the "banking and fiscal system" and providing "social guarantees" appear to have been well covered. I totally trust Mr Repse to get that right; he has had plenty of practice recently. But nowhere can I find any indication that the two "arms" we need to help us move forward of "inward investment" and "supporting Latvian business" have been thought of in a positive sense at all. In fact this climber would appear to be expected to climb upwards whilst someone beats his hands with the tax hammer of increased VAT, increased personal income tax, and the new real estate tax. This paper gives me the feeling that the government do not know where the real money to run the country comes from in the first place. For someone to pay real taxes to support the country, they have to earn it by risk taking business first. The paper is fiscally solid, but totally devoid of humanity. I feel the dead hand of "top down control" old fashioned Socialist/Soviet thinking here.
I am not an economist by education (but note that none of our Latvian economists have covered themselves in glory so far, so I surely could not do much worse than them), but I do have a small business and know what I see around me each day. I already feel battered by events here. And I am noted for being one of the most positive men on the planet. How much worse is it for newly unemployed skilled workers, sacked civil servants and businessmen running S&MEs? There is nothing in this paper to warm their hearts that the government understands how their new job will be created or where the hard money that drives the economy comes from at all. And if only half the government sign the paper it is also hard to see how trust will be created for inward investment from international business. Yes two new banks want to open here, but I guess that they do that to take our Latvian (for Latvian read IMF) money out, not to create new wealth for us.
At some stage in the future, the IMF and EU money must be paid back by Latvia Ltd. This means gaining an income that is higher than the still exorbitant cost of government spending. How Latvian business and society will be developed to create that money needs to be addressed in a note too. Maybe that plan is part of the Top Secret annexes that we the public have not been shown?
Back on the surface, the second earthquake was the publication of the Letter of Intent to the IMF from the Government (and I promise this time no dry humour about the IMF - this is too important for that). This document was signed by the government except for the Tautas Party. The TP clearly have objections about the note but no one I talks to thinks that those objections are for the benefit of Latvia. This was confirmed by the rather damning television telephone poll on the news show Kas Notiek Latvia last night.
But to the document itself. There is a rule in climbing that you keep three point of contact as you move forward. Of course we have all seen free climbers on television doing amazing things and breaking this law. But there are two things to remember when watching this, first they are the absolute best in the world, and second, they usually die early because they fall off. The Latvian government in climbing terms is still a novice and needs to move carefully, especially on a crisis climb like this where the overhangs are large and growing worse as we move upwards. Moving(and changing) everything at once may not be a good plan.
I mention all this because the document raises several thoughts in my mind. Firstly there must be someone clever in the finance ministry who can write good corporate "fiscal speak". There is nothing wrong with this because I wrote the first Membership Action Plan for Estonia to gain NATO membership. But whoever wrote it, the Latvian Government signed it and must take full responsibility for the language and the contents. And inside the note there should be a balance between the fiscal social engineering required by the bureaucrats of the IMF and EU, and the reality of running a living, breathing country of real people. This takes compromise, intelligence and strong leadership.
What is worrying is that as far as climbing out of this crisis, the two "legs" of strengthening the "banking and fiscal system" and providing "social guarantees" appear to have been well covered. I totally trust Mr Repse to get that right; he has had plenty of practice recently. But nowhere can I find any indication that the two "arms" we need to help us move forward of "inward investment" and "supporting Latvian business" have been thought of in a positive sense at all. In fact this climber would appear to be expected to climb upwards whilst someone beats his hands with the tax hammer of increased VAT, increased personal income tax, and the new real estate tax. This paper gives me the feeling that the government do not know where the real money to run the country comes from in the first place. For someone to pay real taxes to support the country, they have to earn it by risk taking business first. The paper is fiscally solid, but totally devoid of humanity. I feel the dead hand of "top down control" old fashioned Socialist/Soviet thinking here.
I am not an economist by education (but note that none of our Latvian economists have covered themselves in glory so far, so I surely could not do much worse than them), but I do have a small business and know what I see around me each day. I already feel battered by events here. And I am noted for being one of the most positive men on the planet. How much worse is it for newly unemployed skilled workers, sacked civil servants and businessmen running S&MEs? There is nothing in this paper to warm their hearts that the government understands how their new job will be created or where the hard money that drives the economy comes from at all. And if only half the government sign the paper it is also hard to see how trust will be created for inward investment from international business. Yes two new banks want to open here, but I guess that they do that to take our Latvian (for Latvian read IMF) money out, not to create new wealth for us.
At some stage in the future, the IMF and EU money must be paid back by Latvia Ltd. This means gaining an income that is higher than the still exorbitant cost of government spending. How Latvian business and society will be developed to create that money needs to be addressed in a note too. Maybe that plan is part of the Top Secret annexes that we the public have not been shown?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)